GameStop CEO Ryan Cohen criticized publishers moving to digital-only releases, responding to Rockstar Games and Take-Two Interactive's decision to make GTA 6 digital-only. "When you buy a game, you should be able to sell it, trade it, or lend it to a friend," Cohen told Bloomberg. "Unquestionably, the decision to move to all-digital has hurt consumers, and it's also hurt GameStop."

GTA 6's physical edition includes only a download code rather than game discs. The game exceeds 211GB, which would require three standard 100GB Ultra HD Blu-ray discs to contain at launch, making a full physical release impractical. Take-Two Interactive says 98% of its business is now digital but has not ruled out releasing a proper physical GTA 6 edition later.

Cohen's comments carry irony. In July, he stated that physical video games were "irrelevant" to GameStop's business strategy. The company now relies primarily on secondhand game sales, a revenue stream that bypasses original publishers entirely. GameStop says video game software sales currently represent the smallest portion of its business.

GTA 6 has generated $1.38 billion in PS5 revenue alone according to Sensor Tower. Take-Two likely chose digital distribution to avoid manufacturing costs, reverse-engineering risks, and disc production overhead. Retailers still receive a share of profits from selling physical code-in-a-box versions.