GTA 6 introduces a "criminal profile" system that tracks moral choices separately for each protagonist, Jason and Lucia. The worse your actions, the lower your profile drops. Reach "Irredeemable" status and you cannot recover, plus you lose Focus bonuses. Each character's profile is tracked independently, so you can play one as a pacifist and the other ruthlessly without their paths affecting each other.

The system draws from Red Dead Redemption 2's honor mechanic. Playing as a pacifist, only shooting when necessary, offers rewards despite the downsides of extreme criminal profiles. Your choices impact the game's ending.

This marks a departure from previous GTA games. GTA 5's three protagonists, Trevor, Michael, and Franklin, played largely the same despite different personalities and special abilities. Morality played no role in those games. GTA 6 enables separate playstyles and genuine roleplaying between its two leads, letting player choice shape individual character paths.