The Competition Appeal Tribunal in London dismissed a 2.6 billion pound UK class action lawsuit against Sony. The case, brought by Alex Neill on behalf of PlayStation Store customers who bought digital games between August 2016 and February 2026, accused Sony of using the platform's dominant market position to charge "excessive and unfair" prices.

The tribunal ruled that Neill failed to establish Sony violated competition law. The lawsuit claimed PlayStation's dominance trapped game buyers in a closed ecosystem and that the platform's 30% commission fee on developers inflated prices. Neill argued owners of PlayStation hardware had no access to competing storefronts.

The tribunal determined Sony competes in a wider "systems market" against Xbox, Nintendo and PC. The body stated PlayStation had no legal duty to allow third-party stores on its platform. The tribunal also noted that allowing rival storefronts would be "expensive, complex" and carry "potential security ramifications."

The tribunal found Neill provided insufficient evidence that Sony's profit margins were excessive. It ruled there was no proof that rival storefronts on PlayStation would have lowered prices.

The judgment mirrors arguments made against Valve regarding Steam's dominance on PC. A key difference, the tribunal noted, is that PC offers competing storefronts like Epic Games Store and GOG, though PlayStation does not.